Associate Bonus Watch: Willkie Matches, and the Simpson Memo
So it appears that Willkie Farr & Gallagher has matched market bonuses. We don't have official confirmation or a memo yet, but we doubt that this is another fake Willkie announcement.
Matching is the default outcome right now. We doubt anyone will have the guts to raise. Most big law firms had a very good year in 2006, and they probably could afford to be more generous with bonuses. But our guess is that they're being conservative this year, in case the economy heads south in 2007.
On the other hand, we don't think any Biglaw shop would be stupid enough (or mean enough) to go below market. It would be a scarlet letter to wear for several recruiting seasons to come. So matching market / Milbank is the safest way to go.
One of you was kind enough to respond to our request for the Simpson Thacher bonus memo. We reprint the STB memo, after the jump.
Update (1:35 PM): The Willkie Farr memo is also available after the jump. Our thanks to commenter Wendell.
SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT BONUS ANNOUNCEMENT MEMO
From: Ruegger, Pete
Sent: Friday, December 15, 2006 11:18 AM
To: Associates and non-Senior Counsel
Subject: 2006 Bonuses
SIMPSON THACHER & BARTLETT LLP
MEMORANDUM TO ALL ASSOCIATES AND COUNSEL
On behalf of the partners of the Firm, I am pleased to announce that the year-end bonuses for associates in good standing will be as follows:
Class of 2006 - $30,000 (pro-rated)
Class of 2005 - $35,000
Class of 2004 - $40,000
Class of 2003 - $45,000
Class of 2002 - $50,000
Class of 2001 - $55,000
Class of 2000 - $60,000
Class of 1999 - $65,000
(and more senior)
Bonuses for counsel will be determined on an individual basis and communicated to those individuals shortly. Bonuses will be paid on December 29, 2006. Associates and counsel who were on leave or worked part-time during any part of this year will be eligible for a pro-rated bonus.
Thank you for your dedication and professionalism. On behalf of the Firm, I wish all of you and your families a happy and healthy holiday season.
Pete Ruegger
Chairman, Executive Commitee
December 15, 2006
Earlier: Prior ATL coverage of bonuses (scroll down)









Comments
From: The Executive Committee
Sent: Friday, December 15, 2006 11:50 AM
To: ASSOCIATES - NY; ASSOCIATES - DC
Cc: PARTNERS - NY; PARTNERS - DC
Subject: 2006 Year-End Bonus
The Executive Committee is pleased to announce that the year-end bonuses for NY & DC associates in good standing will be as follows:
CLASS BONUS
2006 $30,000 (pro-rated)
2005 $35,000
2004 $40,000
2003 $45,000
2002 $50,000
2001 $55,000
2000 $60,000
1999 $65,000
1998 $65,000
Bonuses will be paid on Friday, December 22nd. As always, associates who have been with the firm for only part of the year or who are working part-time will receive a pro-rated bonus.
On behalf of all of our partners, I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for your continued efforts on behalf of the firm and our clients. We wish you and your families a happy, healthy and peaceful 2007.
Posted by: wendell | December 15, 2006 01:35 PM
I really don't understand why bonuses have all but replaced any interesting topics of conversation these past weeks. (No snark, just genuine wonder.) There are hardly any surprises, and the memos are not exactly models of hilarity. I think it would be more interesting if somebody had an anecdote regarding any performance-based reduction in said bonus (e.g. Partner told me I wasn't getting a bonus because I billed 1200 hours this past year and I sent a typo-riddled S-4 to the printer).
Posted by: FAS | December 15, 2006 01:48 PM
Interesting that both of these firms are paying their bonuses in December rather than January (which I recall most firms that have announced so far as doing). Obviously it all comes out in the wash at the end of the day (er, tax year), but in terms of cash-in-hand, that's better for associates, right?
Posted by: Dan | December 15, 2006 02:19 PM
Why does everyone in law firm management/administration always capitalize the "Firm"? I've always thought that's a little weird.
Posted by: John | December 15, 2006 02:27 PM
Dan, wouldn't the deferral effects of the tax (~1/3 * 12 months inflation) be more than that of getting the money maybe 1 month sooner? Paying in Jan defers the tax until April 2008...
Posted by: lawstudent | December 15, 2006 03:00 PM
Hey lawstudent - even if the income isn't "taxed" until April 2008, taxes will still be withheld (and at a hefty amount, too, because it will be withheld at the maximum rate). If the firm pays in December, you can get your refund all the quicker on those excess taxes withheld in the next April (4 months later, or earlier if you file quickly). However, if you get paid in January, you won't get refunded on the excess taxes paid until the next April (15 months later). That's a pretty hefty no-interest loan to the government.
Posted by: not so tax unsavy law student | December 15, 2006 03:19 PM
I was thinking about two things:
1) In terms of withholding, I believe the new provision is that instead of withholding taxes as if that was your regular paycheck (like they used to), that they now withhold bonus compensation at a flat 15% rate.
2) If they pay the bonus in December, they won't withhold SS taxes, because you're already over the threshold. If they pay it in January, SS taxes get withheld.
There's a thread somewhere on Greedy where they've calculated what the cash difference is between getting your bonus in Dec. vs. Jan.
Posted by: Dan | December 15, 2006 03:29 PM
Davis Polk:
From: Ferrell, Kathleen L. On Behalf Of Management Committee
Sent: Friday, December 15, 2006 3:34 PM
To: Management Committee
Subject: 2006 Associate Bonuses
We are pleased to announce that associates in good standing will receive a bonus payment as outlined below. Bonuses will be paid on December 29, 2006 in the same manner as the regular December monthly paycheck, and will be subject to proration for those who arrived after January 1, 2006 and those on part-time schedules or other special arrangements.
We thank you for your efforts over the past year, and wish you and your family a wonderful holiday season.
Class of 2006: $30,000 (prorated)
Class of 2005: $35,000
Class of 2004: $40,000
Class of 2003: $45,000
Class of 2002: $50,000
Class of 2001: $55,000
Class of 2000: $60,000
Class of 1999 and senior: $65,000
The Management Committee
Posted by: DPW Matches | December 15, 2006 03:49 PM
I think its a flat 25% rate, not 15%. True, re: SS taxes. I think its better to just get it in December as opposed to January
Posted by: Anonymous | December 15, 2006 05:58 PM