Add RSS RSS

DOJ Diva of the Day: Shanetta Y. Cutlar

Shanetta Cutlar Above the Law Department of Justice Civil Rights Division Special Litigation Section Above the Law.jpgThe Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department -- one of the DOJ's most important arms, charged with enforcing our nation's anti-discrimination laws -- has been experiencing some upheaval over the past few years. Several articles in the Washington Post have examined some of the conflicts within the division. See, e.g., here, here, and here.

We've learned that Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee may be taking a closer look at what's going on over at the Civil Rights Division. And when they do, some of their attention may focus on the Special Litigation Section, headed by Shanetta Y. Cutlar.

Here's an explanation of the Section's mission, from its website:

[The Section is] charged with enforcing federal civil rights statutes in four major areas: Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons, Conduct of Law Enforcement Agencies, Access to Reproductive Health Clinics and places of Religious Worship, and Religious Exercise of Institutionalized Persons. The Section undertakes investigations and litigation through the United States and its territories.

The Section Chief is Shanetta Cutlar, an award-winning litigatrix. And even though some attorneys and staff members have alleged that she's "abusive" -- what a subjective word! -- Cutlar is a woman after our own heart. There's nothing we love more than a high-powered female who takes charge of a situation and demands respect from her subordinates. We adore women in leadership roles who follow the teaching of Machiavelli: "[I]t is far safer to be feared than loved."

A former attorney in the Special Litigation Section, Ty Clevenger -- a Stanford Law grad and former law clerk to the highly esteemed Judge Morris Arnold (8th Cir.) -- had some issues with Cutlar and how she ran the Section. Last fall, Clevenger sent a letter to Deputy Attorney General Paul J. McNulty. Clevenger alleged that Cutlar -- whom he described as "extremely intelligent" and "very charming," but also "a Jekyll and Hyde personality" -- created an "atmosphere of fear and paranoia" within the Section.

On October 4, 2006, Ty Clevenger sent his letter to McNulty. Clevenger's office was searched overnight, and he was fired the next day. He is in the process of filing a whistleblower complaint.

Here's the first page of Clevenger's letter to the DAG:

Shanetta Cutlar Paul McNulty 1.jpg

There's more. Juicy details about La Shanetta's alleged behavior are described in the rest of Ty Clevenger's letter. The letter has been distributed to all the Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee (with supporting documentation).

We reprint the entire Clevenger letter, which a source helpfully leaked provided to us, after the jump.

Here's the rest of the letter. Once again, the emphases have been added by us.

PAGE TWO

Shanetta Cutlar Paul McNulty 2.jpg

PAGE THREE

Shanetta Cutlar Paul McNulty 3.jpg

PAGE FOUR

Shanetta Cutlar Paul McNulty 4.jpg

Congratulations, Ms. Cutlar! Many divas walk the halls of Main Justice -- but YOU have been named ATL's DOJ Diva of the Day. Keep up the good work!

P.S. We have more Shanetta-licious documents in our possession. But we're not going to release them all at once, so as not to overload you. Check back soon for more.

Update: We've done several subsequent posts about Shanetta Cutlar. We've provided biographical data about her, described how she terrorized a summer intern, and shared an account of her final confrontation with Ty Clevenger.

To access the complete archives of our Shanetta Cutlar coverage, click here.

Civil Rights Division: Special Litigation Section [U.S. Department of Justice]
IACP 2005 Civil Rights Award Presented to Shanetta Cutlar [International Association of Chiefs of Police]

Comments
avatar
1 Posted by that guy | Permalink Wednesday, January 10, 2007 4:01 PM

Clevenger has a storied history as a whistleblower. While he was at SLS, he uncovered some malfeasance at the campus post office by photographing postal employees throwing mail into dumpsters. Legend has it that the Postmaster General came to Stanford to address the situation.

avatar
2 Posted by guest | Permalink Wednesday, January 10, 2007 4:05 PM

Apparently he was right about the postal service, though.

avatar
3 Posted by guest | Permalink Wednesday, January 10, 2007 5:15 PM

Apparently the guy also enjoys his Readers Digest.
http://stanforddaily.com/article/2000/3/27/postalWorkersCaughtTrashingMail

avatar
4 Posted by HAH | Permalink Wednesday, January 10, 2007 8:44 PM

What a baby!. What is this a damn class action?

avatar
5 Posted by reader | Permalink Thursday, January 11, 2007 2:34 AM

Ty is awesome. Conservative enfant terrible on campus and legendary warrior on the "law-talk" listserv, he's a truly decent human being in person.

The Stanford post office thing was amazing -- that place had turned around so completely within a year of his campaign that it was almost unrecognizable.

If he wrote this letter, he had very, very good reason.

avatar
6 Posted by Joe | Permalink Thursday, January 11, 2007 3:39 PM

I don't know whether he is right or wrong, courageous or sniveling. But I would never use the word "chicanery" in a business communication.

avatar
7 Posted by Eric | Permalink Thursday, January 11, 2007 5:09 PM

Ty is a stand up guy. Cutlar must be an absolute witch (in a non-sexist, totally pc way). Stanford should appreciate Ty's effort at the post-office and the American public should appreciate his services in the Civil Rights Division. I hope this site will be forwarded to prominent attorneys / government officials in order to bring about the changes that need to occur at the DOJ.

avatar
8 Posted by Monique | Permalink Thursday, January 11, 2007 10:42 PM

Ditto re the comments about Ty. I have known Ty for seven years, and while we might disagree on political issues from time to time (he's the social conservative, I'm the libertarian), he has the courage to stand up for his convictions. And I would back his integrity any day. The post office reformation is just one of numerous examples of Ty's character. I don't doubt that this woman is a tyrant.

avatar
9 Posted by guest | Permalink Thursday, January 11, 2007 10:52 PM

"Requir[ing] two employees with six-figure salaries to serve as typists"? Welcome to Big Law...

avatar
10 Posted by Anonymous | Permalink Friday, January 12, 2007 3:38 PM

The REAL facts are .. the Section has lost over 45 employees while Mrs. Cultar has been the Section Chief. And we are not talking about support staff, we are talking about Deputies, Special Council and Attorneys... So one has to wonder WHY??? Apparently there is some truth in this story!!

avatar
11 Posted by guest | Permalink Friday, January 12, 2007 11:39 PM

Glad to see that at least one Shanetta Cutlar post has cracked the Top 10 Most-Emailed list.

I don't know which Shanetta post I like the best. The summer intern one is pretty great. But so is the "Shanetta you are downright evil" one.

avatar
12 Posted by Anonymous | Permalink Saturday, January 13, 2007 11:57 PM

Go Ty! finally... many voices are now being heard and the SOS signal has been launched and received. Hold on SPL folks HELP is on the WAY! DOJ will not let you down, Justice will deliver Justice. Shanetta, if you are reading this, your day is coming!
Ty, you are our hero, no doubt it took great courage to stand up to Ms. Cutlar, your brave actions is paving the way for many SPL "Shanetta hit list victims" to follow. I too, experienced the wrath of Shaneta, going to work each day was pure torture, unfortunately I had to depart DOJ, I could no longer tolerate such cruel mental treatment. I left the department only to be free of her unsuspecting wrath. Watch out folks, she's a slick one, don't let the devil fool you, she's just that good.

avatar
13 Posted by anonymous | Permalink Tuesday, January 16, 2007 5:41 PM

45 out of how many total? anyone know the precentage?

avatar
14 Posted by Anony Mouse | Permalink Sunday, January 21, 2007 9:19 PM

Since she took over, the percentage is roughly around 60-70%

avatar
15 Posted by anthony | Permalink Sunday, January 21, 2007 9:29 PM

I'm so grateful for this story coming to light. It's appalling to see think that a government employee would behave so unprofessionally. It sounds as if Shaneta deserves every little bit of bad press that's thrown at her...her reputation is on the decline

Post Your Comment