Above the Law - A Legal Tabloid - News, Gossip, and Colorful Commentary on Law Firms and the Legal Profession - Blogroll

Add RSS RSS


The Hills Are Alive / With the Sound of... Quinn Emanuel?

Sound of Music Julie Andrews Above the Law blog.jpgSeveral tipsters wrote us about the upcoming firm retreat of Quinn Emanuel -- or the "2008 Firm Hike," as it's officially called. It's taking place from July 9–13, over in... SWITZERLAND!!!

From one incoming QE summer:

I'm summering at Quinn, and I just found out that the annual firm hike is going to be in Interlaken, Switzerland. It's a four-day trip, capped by a 25 km hike in the alps. Summer associate perk watch?

We asked this individual if they're excited about the hike:

Hell yes. Forget ballgames and cooking classes, this is a serious trip. I chose Quinn because of the work hard-play hard mentality and outdoors-y vibe, but this is taking it to another level. It is rough that it's such a short trip, but I'd guess that a bunch of full-time employees will extend it by a few days.

More discussion -- some pro- and anti-hike sentiment, from full-time QE lawyers, plus comment from John Quinn himself (in an email with capitalization!!!) -- after the jump.

One permanent associate didn't share the summer associate's enthusiasm:

Quinn Emanuel usually does its firm retreat over the summer in the form of a hike somewhere in the west. This year they announced that the hike/retreat would take place in Switzerland and last almost one week. Sounds awesome, right? But read the fine print boys and girls: to participate in the trip, you need to kick in $1000 to help defray the costs, and sorry, no spouses are allowed.

Query: if you are enjoying a relatively slow summer that allows you to disappear from your desk for one week, would you really pay $1000 for the privilege of hanging out with your bosses and colleagues in one of the decidedly less exciting European countries? Or would you rather use that time and put that money toward a REAL vacation with your significant other? I honestly wonder if this is some sort of test for associates who are gunning for partner, to weed out the less devoted.

Fair points. But another full-time associate was more positive:

I go on the hike every year and always have a great time. So this was sort of a no brainer. The trend that I have seen is that people who usually are up for the hike every year are considering going to this. People who can't be bothered to go on our regular hikes have shown no interest (despite the fact this will be less hiking than usual).

I admit it is a long way to go for a short time, but I have never been to Switzerland and am pretty excited about it.

Finally, on the financial point, John Quinn points out -- in an email message that employs capitalization, but still falls on the informal side -- that the trip is being heavily subsidized, even for full-time associates:

[The information from your sources is b]asically correct. We will leave on a wed and return mon. True cost is abt $3500 per. Summer associates pay nothing. Associates pay 1k. Partners individually will pay some amount above true cost (not yet determined). Firm picks up the rest. Its a grt deal.

We already have over 100 people signed up to go less than a week after the announcement. This hike is described in the lonely planet guide as the best 1 day hike in swiss.

Sounds fantastic! For the curious among you, the emails describing the firm hike -- the first sent to permanent associates, the second sent to summer associates -- appear below.

They're pretty similar. If you were to generate blackline -- er, make that redline -- versions, you'd see that they're basically identical, except for (1) the "no obligation to come" language, which appears only in the summer associates' email, and (2) the discussion of financial arrangements, which mentions a $1,000 contribution from permanent associates, but no contribution from summer associates.

Swiss Flag Swiss Alps Quinn Emanuel firm hike Above the Law blog.jpgQUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER AND HEDGES LLP -- MEMORANDUM -- 2008 FIRM HIKE -- ASSOCIATES

Sent: Monday, February 25, 2008 10:59 PM
To: Associates; Partners

2008 Firm Hike – Quinn Emanuel Invades Switzerland!

2008 Firm Hike: July 9–13, 2008

The Swiss Alps – Bernese Oberland – Base Camp – Interlaken and Grindelwald, Switzerland

For those of you who thought we just couldn't top last year's hike, we give you the mother of all Firm Hikes! This year we're heading to where it all began, the cradle of modern mountaineering, the Alps. Get your passports ready and dust off your lederhosen, because we are invading Switzerland.

We'll be hiking the "Faulhornweg" trail, a 25-kilometer hike through some of the most spectacular scenery in the world. This hike has been described as the best hike in the Alps because of its classic Alpine beauty and its majestic views of the famous Eiger, Mönch, and Jungfrau peaks. This, of course, is a Quinn Emanuel hike, so get yourself into shape as altitude will be an issue, again. Nevertheless, this will be the hike of a lifetime and one we're sure you're not going to want to miss.

This year we leave on Wednesday afternoon, July 9th, and return Sunday evening, July 13th. We will be staying in the beautiful town of Interlaken, situated between the lakes of Thuner See and Brienzer See. The hike itself will be on Friday, July 11th. Some of you will be overjoyed to know that you can leave your tents and sleeping bags at home as backcountry tent-camping is outlawed in Switzerland. As a result, our base camp will be the luxurious Victoria-Jungfrau Grand Hotel & Spa, see:

http://www.victoria-jungfrau.ch/en/desktopdefault.aspx

As you might imagine, inviting the entire Firm to Switzerland is a major undertaking and traveling to Europe in a big group during summer is logistically complicated and very expensive. If you attend the hike, the firm requires a contribution of $1,000 from each associate. Partners who attend will be required to contribute a significantly greater amount that will be averaged across the attending partners (to be determined later). Your contribution will cover all transportation, hotel and food.

Because of airline requirements, we need a firm commitment from you by THIS FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 29th, 12:00-Noon PST. Please let Selene (not Tigran and not Steve) know.

If you cancel after March 21st for non-approved reasons, you must reimburse the firm for any expenses incurred on your behalf.

See you in Switzerland!

Swiss Flag Swiss Alps Quinn Emanuel firm hike Above the Law blog.jpgQUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER AND HEDGES LLP -- MEMORANDUM -- 2008 FIRM HIKE -- SUMMER ASSOCIATES

Sent: Tuesday, February 26, 2008 7:09 PM
To: Summer Associates

2008 Firm Hike: July 9–13, 2008

The Swiss Alps – Bernese Oberland – Base Camp – Interlaken and Grindelwald, Switzerland

As I told you in an earlier email, the firm hike this year will require a passport. We're heading to where it all began, the cradle of modern mountaineering, the Alps. Dust off your lederhosen, because we are invading Switzerland.

At the outset, I should let you know that while you are all invited to participate, there is absolutely no obligation to do the firm hike. Don't like to hike? Spent way too much time in the Swiss Alps already this year? That's okay by us. The hike is meant to be a fun and challenging event-- not a chore. So don't feel bad if you don't want to come.

That said, this year's hike promises to be spectacular. Tigran, who works with John Quinn to plan the hike each year, has outdone himself. We'll be hiking the "Faulhornweg" trail, a 25-kilometer hike through some of the most spectacular scenery in the world. This hike has been described as the best hike in the Alps because of its classic Alpine beauty and its majestic views of the famous Eiger, Mönch, and Jungfrau peaks. This, of course, is a Quinn Emanuel hike, so get yourself into shape as altitude will be an issue, again. Nevertheless, this will be the hike of a lifetime.

This year we leave on Wednesday afternoon, July 9th, and return Sunday evening, July 13th. We will be staying in the beautiful town of Interlaken, situated between the lakes of Thuner See and Brienzer See. The hike itself will be on Friday, July 11th. You can leave your tents and sleeping bags at home as backcountry tent-camping is outlawed in Switzerland. As a result, our base camp will be the luxurious Victoria-Jungfrau Grand Hotel & Spa, see:

http://www.victoria-jungfrau.ch/en/desktopdefault.aspx

As you might imagine, inviting the entire Firm to Switzerland is a major undertaking and traveling to Europe in a big group during summer is logistically complicated. Accordingly, please let Selene Dogan in the Los Angeles office (she is cc'd) know by March 7 whether you will or will not be coming. The firm will cover all (reasonable) expenses associated with the trip. Please note that if you decide later not to come on the hike (absent a very good reason), you will be expected to reimburse the firm for expenses incurred on your behalf.

I hope you are as excited as we are about this trip! See you in Switzerland!


TrackBack

Use this Trackback URL for this entry:
http://www.abovethelaw.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/14727

Comments

Switzerland - It's a bit hilly, no?

I never really thought of QE as rugged outdoorsy attorneys....

The no-spouse rule is tough. Can't think that many SOs, who rarely get to see their partners thanks to QE's hours, are super thrilled that the firm now expects them to vacation alone.

I thk you shd mastr grammar and type skills b4 writing messgs.

Uh... you know that The Sound of Music was set in Austria, right? Totally different country.

EINS, John Quinn is just trying to learn to write like a Lolcat.

The hotel is great - one of the best wellness places in Europe ...

2:10 - The von Trapp family escaped by hiking over the Alps into Switzerland.

QE = TTT. Swiss junket doesn't chaneg that.

Judging by the type who work at Quinn, they'll be a lot of backwoods buggery going on during that trip!

Did someone really refer to the hotel as a great "wellness" place? Please tell me that this is tongue-in-cheek or I may throw up.

Also, forced marches in the woods as part of the path to partnership seems a little nuts to me.

QE: Disabled and pregnant need not apply.

One of the named partners in the LA office gives the Valentine's Day sexual harassment speeh each year. He says you can F*ck anyone you want, but don't expect it to help your career. Well, this named partner started having an affair with an associate. It definitely helped her career. He divorced his wife and married this associate. The firm no longer lets this named partner give the Valentine's Day speech. Instead, he brought all of the associates to lunch and tried to ease his guilt by rationalizing his choices. He is a douche.

Additionally, the Quinn LA office, although the headquarters, is getting reamed by the NYC office because NYC is significantly overbilling LA. Although Quinn LA sold itself as a "lifestyle-esque" big firm, it is now cracking down on associates. Bill 160 hours one month and someone comes to talk to you.

ATL is very pro-Quinn. Quinn has big problems.

This makes me want to vomit. I can't imagine their clients understand this conspicuous consumption.

agreed, this is ridiculous. short-change the associates come bonus-time, and expect this to change sentiment? come on.

a) LEDERHOSEN have nothing to do with Switzerland, dammit! When will you stupid Americans learn that Germany and Switzerland is not the same country?? Douche bags!
b) The Faulhornweg hike is not a hike - it's boring walking. Nothing about mountaineering, nothing about hight. Though, the scenery will be nice. And you will see a lot of old folks walking the same way...
c) The Victoria Jungfrau? You're kidding me? One of the most prestige and most luxurious hotels in Switzerland. And all they will do is walking a little bit around and play with themselves. Douche bags.

*BANG!*

That's the sound of 2:21 hitting the proverbial nail on the head.

After Quinn got yalepwned during this year's recruiting season, I wonder how the Deer Valley trip will shake down next year.

Why does any partner think this is fun? Another submission for "stuffwhitepeoplelike.com."

2:36 is right. It sounds like an okay trip, but it's not some hard-core outdoor adventure. Pansies.

Lat, ever think that the reason for the capitalization is that he was sending it from his BB (which has auto caps after periods)?? Might also explain the shorthand.

2:51, ever think you're too stupid to live? It's well known that JQ takes an anti-capitalization stance. He thinks it's cool, and the public gives him attention because of it.

All else aside, going hiking with a bunch of lawyers you work with sounds excruciating.

"I chose Quinn because of the work hard-play hard mentality and outdoors-y vibe..."

This is awesome. And by awesome, I mean horrible.

Mike Favs at 2:17 said "Judging by the type who work at Quinn, they'll be a lot of backwoods buggery going on during that trip!"

You say that like it's a bad thing. ??

2:27 - ATL is "very pro-Quinn"?

Don't you remember all the posts from a few weeks ago? TONS of criticism, about everything from bonus calculation for laterals to inadequate office furniture.

At the end of the movie, though, they flee to neutral Switzerland.

I've been to Interlaken before...it's okay if you're into that kind of secluded-spa type thing.
I thought the cities were better, personally. But I'm salivating over the spa packages at that hotel.

I feel like this is another example of the strange cultishness of West Coast firms and their particular brand of Kool-Aid. People really semm to think that their firms are these special little places that are oh so unique.

Obviously NYC has Cravath but even they don't have the weird sort of new-age vibe that Cali firms give off, they're just hardcore.

Sound of Music was in Austria

2:56 ... aka Lat

Stop being a whiny little bitch. No wonder you're such a Hillary fan, neither of you can take any criticism at all.

Look at his message again.

The attorneys were notified late Monday night, and have to decide whether to go by tomorrow. For a week-long trip in July. They have until 3/21 to back out. After that, they get charged.

2:56,

Ever think you should do your own f'ing homework before calling other people stupid? From John Quinn's email to Lat, posted on ATL on January 23, 2008:

"it has been suggested that i do not use capital letters in my typing in an effort to be "cool." i am not cool; wish i was, but after 56 years i don't think it is going to happen. the fact is i am not coordinated enough to hit the shift button with one hand and a letter with the other."
http://www.abovethelaw.com/2008/01/wherein_we_hear_from_john_quin_1.php

Moron. 2:51's speculation sounds pretty plausible to me.

where do i submit my resume?

Obviously, if he says he's not using capitalization to be cool, then it must be true.

don't they play a lot of rugby in Austria?That would be fun to check out while over there.

3:25, you have to use the shift button to get the quotation marks in "cool". jq was obviously lying. dumbass.

3:33,

Let's take a closer look at what JQ said: " the fact is i am not coordinated enough to hit the shift button with one hand and a letter with the other."

Do you have to hold Shift with one hand and press a key with the other to generate a quotation mark? No, the quotation mark key is right above the Shift key, so you can press both with the same hand. Moreover, writing without capital letters doesn't interfere with clarity to the same extent that writing without quotation marks, parentheses, exclamation points, or question marks would, so it's not entirely surprising that Quinn would choose to omit capital letters while making the extra effort to get the punctuation right. I see no reason not to take his word on this.

CAPITALS lower case--no one cares except for the anal ass holes(pun intended) on ATL or should that be atl?

You guys are complaining about a trip to the Swiss Alps? You're nuts.

no spouses?....

is that like an excuse to leave the wives at home?

I wonder how many of the female lawyers at Quinn have wives?

3:20 is right. Short notice.

3:25, you are such clueless tool. Of course he's coordinated enough. He hasn't suffered brain damage or stroke, he doesn't have Alien Hand Syndrome, and he's not 5.

4:20,

How many people over 45 do you know who can't use a computer properly? Yes, I'm sure that Quinn is physically capable of typing capital letters when he needs to, but I also find it perfectly plausible that he prefers not to do so because he finds it awkward and is important enough to get away with not doing it. More to the point, in the absence of any specific reason to think that he's lying, I see no reason to reject Quinn's personal explanation on the matter. I don't see why this is such a difficult concept for you.

I've been to Interlaken in the summer and it is gourgeous. When one arrives by train, the scene is out of a movie: tranquil lake sorrounded by snowcapped mountains and beautiful swiss houses perched along the countryside. The small downtown (can be walked end to end in less than 30 mins) is great too.

I'm jealous.

You are, in all probability, envious.

338 - didn't you ever take a typing class. The proper technique is to hit the shift key with the pinky of one hand and the letter key of your choice with the opposite hand

5:08,

No, in fact, I never took a typing class, and I tend to scoff at those who needed one. My point remains valid: Quinn's purported lack of coordination, which, according to him, makes typing capital letters awkward, would not prevent him from using a single hand to hold Shift and the quotation mark key. You also failed to respond to my second point, which is that he might be inclined to put the necessary effort into typing punctuation marks even when he is unwilling to do so with capitals.

more pathetic than the honcho who can't be bothered to capitalize words is the lap dog who needs to defend his master.

I went paragliding and hiking in Interlaken in September. Beautiful scenery, terrible food (the big restaurant next to the Victoria-Jungfrau is a Hooters), though there is a decent doner kabob place a few hundred yards from one of the train stations. The casino was lame.

3:38,

Before there were computers, there were typewriters. Do you think JQ went to college? Do you think his professors allowed him to hand in papers without capital letters? Obviously, JQ is coordinated enough to hit two keys simulataneously. It is frankly silly to imagine that someone without a mental or physical handicap is unable to do so.

You base your first point on the assumption that JQ hits the puncutation key and the Shift key with a single hand. It takes more coordination to hit two keys with one hand than it does to hit two keys with two hands. Also, this wouldn't explain how JQ was able to type papers during school.

Your second point betrays the fact that you probably agree that JQ is, in fact, capable of capitalizing his letters, but merely prefers not to. This is irrelevant to the argument that he is capable of capitalizing. Obviously JQ prefers to not capitalize his letters because he DOESN'T capitalize his letters.

You probably shouldn't be an idiot unless you know JQ. I do. I work with him. He gets plenty of attention for himself and for QE thanks to his little quirk. Look, no dress code! No capital letters! Hikes! It's a new kind of attorney!

You're so gullable.

3:55 - you'd be surprised. There's only one straight female partner in the New York office.

oh, and 3:38, you're not only gullable, but you're a dick. What kind of judgmental loser scoffs at someone for taking ANY kind of class. Self-improvement is a good thing.

Well. Hmmm. Actually, I didn't mean to be referring to the afffectional orientation of QE's female attorneys. Most lesbians of my acquaintance do not refer to their spouses as a "wife". What I actually meant to be pointing out, and forgive me if the point was obscure, was the gender-centricity of the commenter who made that little (no doubt, stunningly clever) quip about the hiking trip being an excuse to leave the wives at home. His comment appeared, at least to me, to assume that his audience was entirely male (and heterosexually male, at that).

Well. Hmmm. Actually, I didn't mean to be referring to the afffectional orientation of QE's female attorneys. Most lesbians of my acquaintance do not refer to their spouses as a "wife". What I actually meant to be pointing out, and forgive me if the point was obscure, the gender-centricity of the commenter who made that little (no doubt, stunningly clever) quip about the hiking trip being an excuse to leave the wives at home. His comment appeared, at least to me, to assume that his audience was entirely male (and heterosexually male, at that).

5:38,

I'll spell it out for you simply since you seem to have a problem with big words (see, e.g., "gullable [sic]." Yes, I think Quinn is physically capable of typing capital letters, but I don't think that his email statement suggests otherwise. I also think that his explanation is perfectly plausible. I don't know Quinn; I live on the other side of the country from him, and frankly I never gave a damn about his typing habits until three hours ago. Let's remember how this started: I was replying to 2:56's inane response to 2:51's highly plausible speculation that the Quinn email quoted in the post above contains uncharacteristic capitals because it was written on his Blackberry, which would add them automatically. If Quinn simply avoids typing capital letters because he finds it uncomfortable to do so, rather than in an attempt to be "cool," as 2:56 assumes, then it makes perfect sense that his Blackberry messages would include them; if it were really an image thing, one would think that the great and powerful John Quinn would have had some tech person set his Blackberry to stop auto-capitalizing. I don't really care about it either way, except to the extent that I am usually irritated by cavalier assumptions unsupported by any identifiable evidence.

Do associates get to attend as well?

"oh, and 3:38, you're not only gullable [sic], but you're a dick. What kind of judgmental loser scoffs at someone for taking ANY kind of class. Self-improvement is a good thing."

Lol-- ok, 5:38. I might suggest a remedial spelling class too, then.

Let's go back to 227's "Quinn LA sold itself as a 'lifestyle-esque' big firm."

Wha? When and to whom has QE ever sold itself this way?

I also like the criticism that there isn't enough "mountineering" on this hike. Because other firms offer so much more.

Quinn Emannuel sounds like a great 1L firm. Tons of fun activities and I bet the workload is minor. You get a great summer, earn a bunch of money, and then go to a better firm 2L.

i have no dog in this fight, but "gullable" is an acceptable variant of "gullible" check yourself before you wreck yourself.

let the raging debate as to why JQ capitalizes continue!!

6:45 - very astute. i agree.

3:38, the point you've proven is that you're a dick who I can comfortably ignore. Both "gullable" and "gullible" are correct. Perhaps it's you who needs the remedial spelling class...right after you see your therapist about how you're a dick.

mama, if you're gullible about being gullable, are you gullable-ible, or gullible-able?

You seem to have an unhealthy fixation with dicks, 5:38. Don't worry; whatever shortcomings you may have in that regard are no doubt compensated for by your job carrying John Quinn's briefcase.

P.S. "Acceptable variance" = "common error."

A *hiking* trip? Oh ew.

Do the people who go have to hike? I would love to spend a long weekend relaxing at a spa in the Swiss Alps, but I would never hike them. If I were at Quinn, I'd volunteer to supervise the summers who wanted to laze around the luxurious hotel.

Hey, I'm an associate at QE and I have to say its a little perplexing to read people complaining about either a free or highly subsidized (depending on whether you're a summer or associate) trip to Switzerland, obviously you can't please everyone. I do have to take exception to the claim that we don't do hardcore hikes and that we are pansies. Now I will admit that this year hike is bit of an exception on the hardcore scale, but we have been doing firm hikes for long time. We have hiked in many of the best areas in the west including the Wind River Range, Escalante Utah, and the Bear tooth wilderness in Montana, just to name a few. Personally, I think we are about as hardcore as lawyers come and calling us pansies is comical. A good example is last year's hike. I challenge anyone to name another firm that would take over 60 people on 2 1/2 day hike that covered 32 miles with over 8000 feet of elevation gain (topping out at 14,000 feet). Don't forget that everyone carried roughly 40 pounds of gear (tent, sleeping bag, food, clothes etc.). It may not be as hardcore as summit of Denali or Annapurna, but anyone who has done any trekking or backpacking knows that the hikes we've done are not the stuff of pansies. In addition, I would also mention that in our free time some of us are pretty hardcore mountaineers, tri-athletes, marathoners etc. That being said, I think that we are a pretty diverse place where we allow people have lots of different interests. Nobody has to fit a mold and anyone who works here knows that you don't become a partner by going on the hike, it simply has no effect on your status.

"I chose Quinn because of the work hard-play hard mentality and outdoors-y vibe"

I bet they can hear the douche alarm ringing all the way in Switzerland. Either Quinn summers are @ss-kissing tools, or this particular "summer" just so happens to also be a partner.

The tipper and quite a few of the commenters strike me as a little too gung ho to be summers and associates. QE partners are pathetically transparent.

very macho of you all. Got many brilliant fatties or gimps? How about those pansies that would never think of leaving their families for a week of vacation with co-workers? Bet their partnership prospects are looking up. And I always thought the no-spouse Christmas parties were meant for extra-marital hookups, but nothing like the no-spouse week-long vacay in the romantic alps.

I don't know why this bothers me so much but I guess it does. Sounds like fun as a summer, but as an associate, it feels off.

Is a list available for the top PPPs of 2007?

This is why people hate lawyers. There's so much bitterness/envy in this thread.

I think QE is doing a nice job of trying to break the stuffy mold of a successful big lawfirm. It's fine if this trip is not something you would be interested in, but I certainly don't think they should be criticized over this.

I'm a quinn associate. Can I deduct the $1K from my taxes? I don't hit AMT, so I think the true cost to me is closer to $600. thoughts?

Julie from Cincinnati, no, they don't play much rugby in Austria. England and most Commonwealth countries, France, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Argentina, Georgia and various Pacific Islands are pretty much the only places where it is played.

Was there a joke somewhere in there that I missed?

yeah, like i'm really going to chip in $1000 for quinn's marketing ploy after getting screwed on my bonus. gee - a week long trip in close quarters with the biggest kool-aid drinkers at the firm! giddy-up. on second thought, i'm going to get to 2101 as soon as possible so i can be "sick" for the remainder of the year.

jon steiger is a partner at QE's LA office. a total abusive racist douchebag who has affairs with mentees, summer associates, and associates, marries them and then divorces them...

QE sucks...

8:13: I feel you. This trip actually seems a lot easier than the one I went on, which involved two nights of backpacking. The deal is that John Quinn is an outdoors/exercise enthusiast, and I guess he thinks this helps everyone bond. I think a bigger issue at Quinn is getting associates to feel appreciated and happy.

In any case, I think it's cool the firm does it. They do try hard to make this work. I don't understand why anyone would bash a firm for having something voluntary and subsidized like this. The hike can only be a good thing for summers and associates.

I've said several times that there are lots of things to dislike about Quinn, but there are also lots of things to like. It's a shame that people are most likely to post on a message board when they are frustrated and unhappy. Try to be objective 1:32--if you want to be somewhere else, why aren't you there?

How cruel -- associates have to pitch in $1,000, which they can't afford on a $160,000-$250,000 salary -- for a few days in Switzerland, including airfare, food, and a stay at a resort. Oh the humanity!

Re: the named partner/associate affair, the named partner was "allowed" to give the speech, but as he said, he would not give CLE credit for it. Whether you agree with what he does in his personal life, it really is only his business. He made it explicit that the associate's career was not given special treatment. In fact, the associate is now gone from the firm (voluntarily). I give him credit for facing the rumor mill head on and stating his own case. But so long as there is not favoritism, then I have no business labeling the partner a good or bad person. The associate who left the firm obviously did not become partner, so the issue of whether her career was unfairly advanced as a result of the affair never came up. You are a douche for passing judgment so harshly.

9:19: that's the way i see it. but i guess i don't understand why he was "stating his case" at a quasi-mandatory valentine's day luncheon. this is a law firm, not the sally jessy raphael show.